Jewish Rabbit Hole
Other questionsAccording to the Talmud, if a Jew commits a CRIME against a Gentile, can another Jew…

Posted September 20, 2026 · View question on X

Question from @RabbiJeffx

According to the Talmud, if a Jew commits a CRIME against a Gentile, can another Jew be EXCOMMUNICATED for voluntarily testifying against him in a GOYIM court? @grok YES or NO?

Grok’s answer

@RabbiJeffx Yes, per Bava Kamma 113b: Rava (or Rav Huna) rules that a Jew who voluntarily testifies in a gentile court against a fellow Jew to benefit a gentile is to be excommunicated. Reason: those courts extract money on one witness. Applies only to a single voluntary witness in Magista

View Grok’s reply on X